(480) 656-7301
call for free consultation
Posted on November 8, 2025 in Criminal Defense
Wondering whether to accept a plea bargain is one of the most common questions defendants face when charged with a crime. Prosecutors often offer a deal early on in the case, promising less severe penalties in exchange for your guilty plea.
This offer may seem tempting — especially if you’re worried about a trial or just want to put the whole incident behind you. However, accepting a plea deal is a big decision with lasting consequences. Knowing the basics can help you make an informed choice and avoid regrets down the road.
Many defendants wonder why the prosecution would offer a plea deal instead of taking the case to trial. The reality is that most criminal cases are resolved through plea deals.
Here’s why the state usually does this:
With heavy case volumes and limited resources, criminal courts can quickly get overwhelmed. Plea bargains enable prosecutors to quickly and efficiently resolve cases that might otherwise clog court schedules for months or years, allowing the court to concentrate its time and attention on more severe cases.
Even when prosecutors believe a defendant is guilty, not all cases are guaranteed to result in a victory at trial, sometimes due to unreliable witnesses, legal hurdles, or issues with the evidence. Offering a plea deal is a way for the state to secure at least a partial conviction and impose a penalty, rather than risking that a jury may acquit a defendant altogether.
The trial process can be extremely taxing and emotionally painful for victims and witnesses, who may need to testify in public and relive traumatic experiences before a jury. Plea bargains spare them from this and can lead to a quicker and less stressful resolution.
While the best outcome is to walk away without a conviction of any kind, there are situations in which a plea deal might be the best option.
Here’s when this could be a wise decision:
If prosecutors have put together a convincing case and have many solid witnesses testifying against you, taking a case to trial might be too risky. In situations like this, accepting a fair plea can help you avoid the harshest outcomes.
In many cases, the sentence you will receive if you go to trial and are found guilty is going to be significantly harsher than what you would be sentenced to if you accept a plea deal. Many people refer to this as the “trial tax,” which means just the act of going to trial often leads to a harsher sentence by the judge.
Criminal proceedings are stressful, expensive, public, and can take a considerable amount of time. When you choose to plead guilty, it speeds up the entire process and makes everything less stressful in many cases. If your goal is to get the case resolved quickly, this can be a good option.
Ultimately, accepting a plea is a personal decision. Your lawyer can guide you, but can’t choose for you.
Before deciding if you will plead guilty or not, there are different factors to consider. Here’s what you should keep in mind:
For many people, the deciding factor is whether or not they are guilty. If they aren’t guilty, they won’t accept a plea deal. While this sounds reasonable, it’s actually not uncommon for innocent people to plead guilty.
If a guilty plea is the better option, even if you are innocent, accepting it is permissible. However, be aware that you will need to admit to an act you did not commit, and ensure you are comfortable with this admission.
Consider how a conviction will affect your job, immigration status, housing, professional licenses, or child custody. Some plea deals bring consequences years after a case is closed. For example, if you’re not a United States citizen, a conviction could potentially lead to deportation. When you go to rent a house or get a job, a sentence — which comes from a guilty plea — will show up and may hurt your chances.
Plea deals often reduce penalties, but be sure they actually make a difference. Does the agreement help you avoid jail time or dismiss more serious felony charges? Maybe you’re offered a deal that lets you plead guilty to an offense that can be expunged in the future. If the plea deal isn’t any better than what you’d get at trial if you lost, then there may be no reason to accept one.
Deciding on a plea deal is never an easy call. The reality is that sometimes a plea deal is a good idea, and sometimes it’s not. It’s very case-specific, and you need to weigh all factors appropriately.
For more information, contact the criminal defense attorney Craig Orent. Give us a call at (480) 656-7301 or visit our law office at 11811 N Tatum Blvd UNIT 3031, Phoenix, AZ 85028. We offer a free case evaluation, so get the help you deserve today.
